The area around Butcher's Island can be good for trout and redfish year-round. Fish the edges of the cut and the flats to the north and south. The best time for trout is in the spring and the best time for redfish is in the fall.

A history of fishing reports for Butcher's Island. Maybe you can find a seasonal pattern or a bait or technique that has worked in the past.

Jun-06-07 • Trout are fair to good at Butcher and Dub's Islands on bone Trout Killers and Bass Assassins.
Aug-20-03 • Trout and redfish are fair to good near Dub's and Butcher's Island on topwaters, live shrimp and glow plastics.
Jun-25-03 • Trout are fair to good at Butcher and Dub's Island son bone Trout Killers and Bass Assassins.
Jun-04-03 • Trout are fair to good at Butcher and Dub's Island on bone Trout Killers and Bass Assassins.
Jun-13-01 • Whiting, flounder, kingfish and sheepshead are good on fresh dead bait at thejetties. Redfish are good on topwaters while drifting the flats around Butcher's Island.